Aaron, this is a niche game. Basically you are coming to this game, not a fan of this niche, and telling us that we need to drop the niche and do what everybody else does. Oh and by the way, there is no guarantee that it will be a success if we do drop the niche.
I recommend that you try one of 1000's of other mmos out there that are mass marketed to players like you.
What? I don't wanna turn this into any other game. I want Perp to be Perp. But if a system is flawed, like time based progression is in a MMO according to me, and if the population in the game you like is at a all time low, and you don't want that game to die, well then me and many others start looking for ways to get the game to where it should be. You know. Have a dialogue about. And a thing that many of us think is holding new peeps off from staying in the game is the GAP that many new player feel they have to the old players. And the feeling that they can't ever close that GAP, so wtf stay. And they leave.
I personally could care less since I have 2 characters with 500k+ EP, and Inda has with 1.5k+ EP etc. It ain't about me or us that want something like this. We only wan't something that might make more peeps stay with the game. It's about a system we think can be tweaked to suit more people. We still are talking bout a keeping the time based progression, but giving new players more EP from the get go. Read up on Indas suggestions if you've missed it. And as we said, this ain't the only solution to the population-problem. But it could be one. So why not do something about it. Nothing bad can outa it. Except some EP-hugging peeps that think their EP is the most important thing in the game, and no new players should come here and *** dat up!!! Well guess what. Vets are the backbones of this game, but the new players are the future of it. We need them to stay for the game to truly thrive. If that can happen without suck a change in reasonable time. OK. But if it doesn't, and steam was released, and 2-3 months from now we still sit with 100-200 players ingame. Then we've missed a big oppurtunity to maybe have some of them ingame. But only time will tell I guess.
The only thing I want is for the game to succeed.