Topic: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

So i tested them on the dedicated bot for suppressing in fact a zenith Mk2

at this point the only skill needed to make it allready so overpower in my opinion is only advanced robo to get the bonus from the bot for the range bonus on suppressor. But i will still speak about it with all the ewar skill to lvl 10 that mean :
-complex jamming electronics
-jamming electronics
-long distance electronic warfare
-sensor suppressing
-advanced robotics
-spec. obs. robot control

with that the stat on a suppressor T4 on this zenith mk2 With no suppressor tuning and nothing else in head slot are:
112 Ew strength
-40% locking range
124% locking time
700m optimal range

now if we add 4 suppressor tuning in head slot :
112 Ew strength
-65% locking range
327% locking time

700m optimal range

in my opinion it's realy to overpower
i tested it on a gropho who was able with 2 amplifier t4 to  lock at 1148m  with the 2 suppressor applyed on him he was only able to lock at 142m i am not speaking about locking time at this point since it's allready not a matter since your locking range is too low.

something need to be changed on this suppressor tunning in my opinion

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

This does seem very powerful however you have to factor in that the Zenith Mk2 is a very specialised robot and even then it can shut-down 1 target completely or chance managing two targets (Depending on their sensor strengths.

If you have a pocket Zenith Mk2 with you for every enemy you're fighting you've already won no matter what robots they're in surely. Suppression will always be something that is considered over powered or underpowered depending how it is used. A mechanic change to never be 100% successful might help this but then what's the point of using it if it won't be successful when you need it to be.

3 (edited by Whys 2012-05-11 21:21:57)

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

what i mean is suppressor got a base of -25% range and the only think that can change it atm is bonus bot from intakt and zenith.
with the add of the tunning, it turn the suppressor in something that can ECM you better than any ECM.
in my opinion it's not the primary effect intended for suppressor but more an increase of your locking time to make a good combo with ECM.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

we are back to beta now?

its two different factions ewar systems... each of them should be powerfull on their own...

but i have seen to powerfull supression already two years ago. someone who has a lockrange under 100m doesnt need to be ecm'ed anymore.

those tunings feel like they go implemented without the corresponding mechanic change.

*Disclaimer: This post can contain strong sarcasm or cynical remarks. keep that in mind!
Whining - It's amazing how fast your trivial concerns will disappear

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

For feedback on the enWar tunings.
No tunings, max skills, t4+ neuts, lets you neut for 634 AP per neut.
2 tunings(the most you can reasonably fit on an ictus mk2) will give you about 991 AP neuted.
This however requires you to sacrifice 2 leg slots, slots that could otherwise be used for things like injectors and evasives.
Overall they do not seem to be unbalanced to me.
Only when you put 3/4 of them on an Ictus mk2 with everything maxed do they go mad, but you can't reasonably pull that off, since without a shield you will die from everything.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

While i agree that does seem over powered. But you will never see that bot by itself, One Vaga can shut that bot down if that zenith isn't focusing on the vaga, and even if it is your leaving all the dps that are with the vaga to kill you. This isn't that overpowered as all 3 EW mechs are fleet bots.Is that fit really what you would run? If it is your combat multiple is only X1(your only taking one bot out of the fight) thats not helpful as your taken out of the fight for the exchange. If your running a full rack of suppressors your combat multiple is x3 your can double suppress 3 enemys. A likely fit for the zenith with these new tunings will be 4 suppressors 2 tunings it will lower your over all combat multiple but increase your over all effectiveness.

All that up there being said it all boils down to your fleet vs enemy fleet also. If enemy has no E-war they are likey going to lose any how. To much E-war not enough DPS they will most likely run away.

Anonymous: lobo is the only hero left in this god foresaken game / :also, Lobo is god among men
http://killboard.sequer.nl/?a=agent-his … mp;month=7 Best month 104 to 1 k/d

7 (edited by Whys 2012-05-12 11:28:38)

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

well 1 zenith with suppressor at -65% locking range  don't need to apply 2 suppressor on the same bot. and the vagabond needed to shutdown this zenith with ECM will need a lest 3 range extender to get is ECM optimal range near 700m were  the zenith is running whitout any range extender. so no sorry this zenith will be way mutch too overpower than any vagabond could be.

there is no bot in this game not even with farlock nexus and 2 amplifier  when suppressed by -65% locking range who could lock at more than 500m. so only 1 suppressor for 1 target is enought.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Lobo wrote:

While i agree that does seem over powered. But you will never see that bot by itself, One Vaga can shut that bot down if that zenith isn't focusing on the vaga, and even if it is your leaving all the dps that are with the vaga to kill you. This isn't that overpowered as all 3 EW mechs are fleet bots.Is that fit really what you would run? If it is your combat multiple is only X1(your only taking one bot out of the fight) thats not helpful as your taken out of the fight for the exchange. If your running a full rack of suppressors your combat multiple is x3 your can double suppress 3 enemys. A likely fit for the zenith with these new tunings will be 4 suppressors 2 tunings it will lower your over all combat multiple but increase your over all effectiveness.

All that up there being said it all boils down to your fleet vs enemy fleet also. If enemy has no E-war they are likey going to lose any how. To much E-war not enough DPS they will most likely run away.

too much Ewar and not enough DPS will in most cases win unless drastically out numbered... for every Ewar mech you field you can take1.5x the size of your current fleet if you are well rounded and know what the hell your doing.

example: 1 ictus (dedicated pilot) 1 zenith (dedicated pilot) 1 Vaga (dedicated pilot) or what ever mix you want and 2 to 3  /Kain or Arti could take a force of 8 to10 to  easy if they are skilled and know how to pvp .. its been done.

Tux ~ Kill the messenger, he was part of it all along.
Euripides ~ Ten soldiers wisely led will beat a hundred without a head.
Bertrand Russell ~ War does not determine who is right - only who is left.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Whys wrote:

there is no bot in this game not even with farlock nexus and 2 amplifier  when suppressed by -65% locking range who could lock at more than 500m. so only 1 suppressor for 1 target is enought.

As things are with reasonably similar fleets, if your enemy has an Ictus and you don't, your at a disadvantage in that engagement.

Wouldn't this be the same thing, in general? Not to mention the boost in neuting capablility.

Also, the more tuners installed, the fewer targets you can lock down, even if you only use (1) module per bot; although using 2 modules is more about covering for fails, so you take a risk only using (1).

There's alot of possible fleet combinations. I'm sure there are alot of them where a single zenith could turn the tide, but there's also just as many where at best they'll even the odds. But that's true even without tuners.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Tux wrote:
Lobo wrote:

While i agree that does seem over powered. But you will never see that bot by itself, One Vaga can shut that bot down if that zenith isn't focusing on the vaga, and even if it is your leaving all the dps that are with the vaga to kill you. This isn't that overpowered as all 3 EW mechs are fleet bots.Is that fit really what you would run? If it is your combat multiple is only X1(your only taking one bot out of the fight) thats not helpful as your taken out of the fight for the exchange. If your running a full rack of suppressors your combat multiple is x3 your can double suppress 3 enemys. A likely fit for the zenith with these new tunings will be 4 suppressors 2 tunings it will lower your over all combat multiple but increase your over all effectiveness.

All that up there being said it all boils down to your fleet vs enemy fleet also. If enemy has no E-war they are likey going to lose any how. To much E-war not enough DPS they will most likely run away.

too much Ewar and not enough DPS will in most cases win unless drastically out numbered... for every Ewar mech you field you can take1.5x the size of your current fleet if you are well rounded and know what the hell your doing.

example: 1 ictus (dedicated pilot) 1 zenith (dedicated pilot) 1 Vaga (dedicated pilot) or what ever mix you want and 2 to 3  /Kain or Arti could take a force of 8 to10 to  easy if they are skilled and know how to pvp .. its been done.


Yes, Ewar is already OP in general.

Population graphs

<GM Synapse> please don't abuse our fresh players before blowing them up. And for god sakes, don't do that after it!

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Generally speaking, if we nerfed ERP we could effective balance this whole situation.

Steam achievement Unlocked:  Being a Badass
http://www.perp-kill.net/kill/239407
Dev Zoom: I think its time to confess, Ville is my alt
Dev Zoom: Ville can be sometimes so sane it's scary.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

my question would be:

how many modules do i have to equip to counter such boosted ewar.

Sensor supressor tunings work ontop of supressor - while you can only use two supressors on one target, the target can only fit two sensor amps to counter. With the new EW tunings, there is only the ECCM counterfit which only loweres the CHANCE to get hit, but does not lower the effect if you got hit by a supressor.

*Disclaimer: This post can contain strong sarcasm or cynical remarks. keep that in mind!
Whining - It's amazing how fast your trivial concerns will disappear

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Annihilator wrote:

my question would be:

how many modules do i have to equip to counter such boosted ewar.

Sensor supressor tunings work ontop of supressor - while you can only use two supressors on one target, the target can only fit two sensor amps to counter. With the new EW tunings, there is only the ECCM counterfit which only loweres the CHANCE to get hit, but does not lower the effect if you got hit by a supressor.

The tuners don't effect signal strength do they, nor range? So those remain unchanged. So the counter remains the same as now, the only difference is in the effect of the supression. (This is the only one I'm familiar with).

What I suspect will be the trade-off, is replacing range-extenders with tuners; that is range for added effect, or putting in 1 of each. But it's really going to depend on what your trying to accomplish. The shorter your supression range, the closer you'll need to be to the blob, and if your locking down counter-ewar, that leaves their dps open to attack and drive you back, probably out of range. So, multi-tuner setups will endup being front line counter-dps, while range-ext fits will be for rear-line counter-ewar.

Yes, the MK II will be dangerous with either a little extra range, supression, or an additional target (2 fully, or 4 partial), but that's true for any MK II.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

@arga  : the ECM tunning affect the EW strength of ECM and suppressor. and BTW a zenith fit for ECM and/or suppress don't need any range extender you have allready more range than needed just with the bonus from the bot.

with all skill at lvl 10 ( long range EW adv robo and spec obs in fact) with not range extender a zenith can ECM suppress at 700m when a vaga can only do it at 490m.

any zenith pilot fitted for suppressing will never fit a range extender it's useless and a waste of head slot. especialy if you get someone with EW nexus to support you.


the question about the suppressor tunning is that they become really to overpower on a zenith or intakt with the combination of their bot bonus.

15 (edited by Arga 2012-05-15 19:08:41)

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

That's 2 different mods though?

In OP your pointing out that with supression tuning, the lock/time supression is huge. That's true, but above your saying that using the ECM tunings give it too much ECM at range.

ECM T4 uses 85 acc vs. 18 for supressor, that's why the Vag has acc reduction. Assuming both are shielded, the Zen is going to break its own cap trying to run 2 ECM's without that bonus reduction.

There's only (5) head slots on the MK I, you could fit (2) of each tuner (depending on CPU) and have (1) strong-Med range supressor, but then you're simply leveling the field. That is 1 bot neutralizing 1 bot, which isn't OP. I say med range, because while 700m is longer than the Vag's 490m, heavy mechs can still target and shoot from 700+ m, meaning you'll be too far away to supress or ecm them anyway; and Zeniths are notoriously squishy even with sheilds.

Meanwhile, the Vaga, with (2) ECM tuners and (3) ECMs, can keep (3) targets locked down. But, the zenith should be supressing the vaga anyway, but without ECM tuners the zenith is probably going to need (3) supressors on the vaga. Again though, that's 1-1 bot negation, which isn't OP.

The difference between supression and ECM is simple, ECM stops DPS completely. That DPS bot can be 10m from you, and you're still OK. Supression however, only shortens the range, so that DPS bot can run right up to your front line and start doing its' thing.

Any EW mech with external support, energy transfer, RSA, Nexus, RR, ect is going to be alot more powerful than it would be alone.

It the tunings are OP, they're OP for ALL ewar mechs, not just Zeniths.

Edit: Also note, that BOTH tuners increase the acc useage. Did you run the zenith with (4) tuners on the test server? It would be interesting to know if it's even cap stable with (1) suppressor. With only (3) leg slots, LWF, Sheild stock, maybe 1 recharger would balance it.  Also, getting everything (ewar and accum, ect) skills to 10 takes a long time. I can see getting ewar/adv robot there, but not all the accum skills too; at least not yet.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

arga the suppressor tunning add there effect after the bonus apply from the bot.
bot bonus that allready change it from -25% range to  -40% on a zenith or intakt.   

getting double suppresse by -25% is not the same than -40%

so acttually getting double suppresse by -40% is the same as getting suppresse only 1 time by -65%

take the exemple of  a kain or tyrannos/artemis.
kain got 275m base  locking range
tyrannos/ artemis got 300m base  locking range

now assuming people got long range targeting at lvl 10 they got +50% for that so we got
412.5m for kain and 450 for the 2 other
most of the people get at least 1 amp on it so +45% from a t4. we are now at :
598m for kain and 653m for tyra/artemis for 1 amp
867m for kain and 946m for tyra/artemis for 2 amp

not get them double suppress by -25%
kain 598*0.75^2=336.4m       867*0.75^2=488m 
tyra/artemis 653*0.75^2=367m      946*0.75^2=532m

then double suppress by -40% done by zenith and intakt only actualy
kain 598*0.6^2=215m       867*0.6^2=312m 
tyra/artemis 653*0.6^2=235m      946*0.6^2=340m

now take this new 4 suppressor tuning on a zenith so the -65% range bonus and suppress with only 1
kain 598*0.35=209m       867*0.35=303m 
tyra/artemis 653*0.35=228m      946*0.35=331m

so as you can see 1 of this suppressor with 4 new tunning is allready more effective than 2 of actual suppressor just in suppressing locking range.

and i won't even go in the discussion about a vaga can lock down 3 target  etc etc
with the new ECM tuning you can fit 1 on a zenith and you allready got 76% EW strength when a vaga with no tunning and same skill got only 74% and you know the hudge difference between this 2 bot 1 can ecm with less accu at 525m when the other can ecm for more accu but at 700m. you will tell me than the vaga can fit a range extender to conpence the ECM tuning of the zenith but that would still let him at 603m  still less than the zenith.

so with ECM tuning Zenith just because of their EW range bonus are becomming even more supperior  in comparison to a vagabond.

when i created this topic i was speaking only for suppression tunning because i wanted to stay on the suppression and what i founded totaly stupid was this bonus for -x% locking range on this tunning.
but yeah we can elarge that to the ECM tuning to. and you will see again that the add of this 2 tuning are letting the vagabond become a useless bot in comparison with the zenith.

Why people would spend EP on a vaga when you can do the same job from far away and with the same EW strengh just for a little more accu conso. Tell me ?

now with this 2 tunning the best bot to do 1v1 is now a zenith mk2 with time you can kill whatever you want and the target will never be able to fight back  if you know how to fit your zenith with the good setup.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Arga, nice calculation there -

ECM stops DPS for as long as the target needs to Re-lock. without any secondary effect, a dual sensor amped veteran locks you in under 4 seconds, your ECM cycles with 10s.

supressor got a dual effect - they reduce your locking RANGE and increase your locking time. If you can reduce your targets locking range below your teams combat range -> he cannot do ANYTHING.

There is a reason why the supression extension got changed from giving a lockrange reduction bonus to only time increase, and that you can only use max 2 supressor on one target AND that the lockrange reduction bonus of the yellow ewars got reduced to 2% per lvl.

The accumulator consumption increase of ew tuners on supressors is not that much - they dont need that much AP to begin with (ECM needs 4.25 times the Acuumulator)

but after all, my only concern is the missing counter for supression tunings.

there are counters to the ecm's chance to hit, there is a counter for neuts boosted amount -> but there is none vs the increased locktime/lockrange reduction.

*Disclaimer: This post can contain strong sarcasm or cynical remarks. keep that in mind!
Whining - It's amazing how fast your trivial concerns will disappear

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Whys wrote:

now with this 2 tunning the best bot to do 1v1 is now a zenith mk2 with time you can kill whatever you want and the target will never be able to fight back  if you know how to fit your zenith with the good setup.

1v1 ?? There is no 1v1 balance.

The best a Zenith mk II could do is fight to a draw. It doesn't have enough DPS to break a repper tank or shield, and if your target isn't shooting, they have plenty of acc for repair.

If I was going to 1v1 in an ewar, I'd choose the ictus over a Zenith.

You completely ignored the accumulator issues associated with using the tuners and ECM on a Zenith. Supression, yes the Zenith can probably manage that, and they could probably 'spot' hit with the ECM to maintain cap, but why would you put on an ECM that you can only use maybe 2-3 times in a battle, instead of another supressor.

Again, in your example of 4 tuners, the zenith is shutting down 1 bot, 2 if its a MK II, although I'd bet there's not enough acc to run 2 supressors with 4 tunnings stable.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Annihilator wrote:

Arga, nice calculation there -

ECM stops DPS for as long as the target needs to Re-lock. without any secondary effect, a dual sensor amped veteran locks you in under 4 seconds, your ECM cycles with 10s.

Its a game of ifs and thens, but you can't stack all the ifs.

If there are (3) vet DPS on your front line, and they're all targeting your vaga, I'd say run away. If its 2, then you manage your cycles on your 3 ecms.

It's also important to note, that the zenith locking range is shorter then it's supressor range, so either you have to use RSA or use up a head slot.

If you start adding in follow bots and RSA for the ewar, then you have to add in that for the targets too.

With a sheild and (3) supressors, and OK acc skills, I'm in the good stable range. But a few volleys of damge without any sheild tuners, and i'll have to fall back or break cap. and then be out of range of my ewar target. With tuners and supressors running, even if its only 2% more, its going to be touchy for cap stablity.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

you know arga the ictus is not the only bot that can drain and neut. and since the drain/neut tunning are leg slot a zenith can use them to.

i don't want to be bad about you but seriously stop speaking when you didn't even checked the new module.
an ictus in 1v1 against a zenith mk2 would be more useless than a tyrannos.

and again i take the exemple of  4 suppressing tuning to show you how stupid they are in fact you don't even need them on a zenith to allready be able to make you'r target not even able to lock you and then fight back at you.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

1 v 1 again? What game have you been playing? There is no 1 v 1 balancing.

I didn't say anything about Ze vs Ictus 1v1, I said given the choice in battle, between having a Zenith or an icuts on my side, I would want the Ictus on my side. Preferrably both.

But I'll quote myself, because anni makes a good point

It the tunings are OP, they're OP for ALL ewar mechs, not just Zeniths.

22

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

I read what has been said here and the one thing that i agree with is that there needs to be a reasonable counter to suppressing. Sensor Amp's are not counter to suppressing if that is what the Devs are thinking.

What i think should happen is the module gets split into two classes one is for locking range and one is for locking time. the suppressor doing both (even with out tuners) is hard to defend against.

i think suppressors should only be able to reduce locking time / used in conjunction with a ecm makes sense.

A new ewar mod should be made to reduce locking range

could you imagine if the neut not only took away accum but lowered your recharge rate and or how much accum you could gain back from injectors / rechargers ? thats kinda the same thing with suppressors it effects two attributes at once.

I think in general the new tuning is a "step" in the right direction for ewar but they need to be notched down quite a bit before the live server.

Tux ~ Kill the messenger, he was part of it all along.
Euripides ~ Ten soldiers wisely led will beat a hundred without a head.
Bertrand Russell ~ War does not determine who is right - only who is left.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

Tux -  I see what your saying, but the capability of range/time is present now, without tuners.

As anni pointed out, and he was being conservative with 4s lock times, many have 3s, even a 200% increase is only 6 seconds, which is still slower then ECM cycle time. With (4) tuners and a 327% time increase (by Why's numbers), that puts it just shy of 10s; but with (4) tuners there's no slot for an ECM.

Basically, lock time isn't as big an impact as the range reduction; because ranging can do double duty, of making them need to come closer and making them relock, without needing an ECM module.

But range supression alone too, would not be very beneficial. If you change their distance to 200m, they can move in and lock you in 4s, and even if you have an ECM, relock in 4s, and still have 60% of thier dps (6s out of 10s ECM cycle).

The trouble here then, is neither range or time is effective by itself. Meaning if they were split, you would need 2 modules for each target, and to double supress then, you'll need 4 modules, leaving only 1 slot.

What would likely happen if they were split, is no one would use the lock time module at all, and Z would fit range supression and ECM modules

Just a side note. Neuts do double duty. Because both offense and defense modules use accumulator, each cycle reduces the targets ability to both defend and attack.

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

i dont like the tunings for the fact that they scratch the delicate balance between ECM and Supressor. It took almost a year and several patches to find at least a bit of balance wher both modules can be used individually and neither is to much overpowered.

and another year to get ECCMs boosted to a state where they are usefull on ANY bot.

*Disclaimer: This post can contain strong sarcasm or cynical remarks. keep that in mind!
Whining - It's amazing how fast your trivial concerns will disappear

25 (edited by Lemon 2012-05-16 01:52:43)

Re: Suppressor Tuning Feedback

GUYS OMG DID YOU HEAR!

LIKE I JUST HURD THAT YOU SHOULD LIKE MAYBE JUST POSSIBLY TRY AND LIKE OH IDK COUNTER FIT A EWAR HEAVY ENAMY!!!!!!

I MEAN WOULDA THOUGHT FITTING TWO SENSOR AMPS AND A ECCM TO KILL A COUPLE EWAR MECHS WOULD WORK WITH OUT MY DAMAGE  TUNNINGS!!!!!

ITS MIND BLOWING!

Seriously? 1 T4 ECCM against those skills is a near 50/50 chance to land with double sensor amps good luck stoping me.

Oh you didnt fit a ECCM well guess what e-war is going to kick your *** because you wanted to shoot farther or harder.

Undefeated 2013
"Even alone you probably are one of the best" - Khader Khan
"Lemon the 1 man army .... also know as: THE TERMINATOR!" - Obi Wan
"There are people who are just better then you at doing many things at one time, some are far better then myself, far better." -Merkle